The core of this argument is that muslim extremists are not bad people, which is inarguably false.

Opening your mouth about privelaged information/fraternizing with organizations/individuals you're currently at war with is *heresy,* an act technically punishable by the death penalty. Solitary confinement isn't bad if you're a decent person who likes themself. This guy however is screwed, because he's gonna have nothing but time to reflect on what a douche he is.